On Tuesday I had the opportunity, for the last time in the Manitoba Legislature, to watch the provincial Throne Speech from the vantage point of an elected member. I have now seen more than 20 such speeches both being in government and being in opposition. Surrounding the Throne Speech, which marks the beginning of a new Legislative Session, is a great deal of ceremony and tradition, with military salutes and the firing of cannons. The Speech is written by the government, but it is read by the Lieutenant Governor of the day.
What is true of all Throne Speeches is that they are documents that are largely aspirational. That is to say, they set out broad strokes of what to expect from a government in the coming year but provide little details. Those details are usually only found several months later when the budget is released. In Manitoba, the provincial budget usually comes in the spring so Manitobans will be waiting a bit longer for details around some of the things they heard Tuesday.
And those details matter. They matter a lot.
Take for example the pledge by the NDP to, in the spring budget, bring forward significant tax relief to middle class Manitobans. There were not details around this promise, but we know from past promises, they often don’t match the buildup. Many remember a promise by the NDP last year to freeze the price on milk. That would seem like welcome relief, until it was announced a few days after, it would only be on one litre cartons. There are not many families who are purchasing a single litre of milk for their families needs.
Then came a promise to remove the provincial sales tax on all groceries. It didn’t take Manitobans long to realize that there were virtually no provincial taxes on groceries already at the time that the promise was made. The fact is that the NDP have made lots of noise about affordability measures but when they are actually unveiled, Manitobans are either not seeing any impact or by such small amounts it is hardly noticed. So, we are left to wait till spring to see what tax relief may come, who it will apply to and how long it will last.
Some welcome news finally came in the Throne Speech for Steinbach residents who have been impacted by flooding over the past two years. After denying repeatedly the request for Disaster Financial Assistance (while offering it to other parts of the province facing similar disasters), the Throne Speech indicated that impacted Steinbach residents would get some support after all. Again, there were little details given about how residents would qualify and how much support would be provided, but it was at least a welcome recognition that Steinbach residents had been treated unequally.
Many of the stakeholders who were at the Throne Speech expressed the need to see further details before passing judgement on announcements in the Speech. This was particularly true for health care announcements that didn’t provide details on where staff would be coming from to operate any new facilities. These are also details that will have to come later for people to feel confident that promises can be kept.
Because of the history and ceremony, Throne Speech days are always unique and exciting. What comes of the actual commitments in the Speech, however, are rarely known until further details are provided.



